Balancing Scale and Yield: My Self-Storage REIT Strategy

Self-storage has quietly become one of the most resilient corners of real estate. Demand for secure, affordable storage space continues to grow, and REITs in this sector have delivered steady income streams for investors. Within my portfolio, CubeSmart (CUBE) has long been the anchor—an established, institutional-backed giant with hundreds of properties nationwide. Its scale, diversification, and reliable dividend history make it a cornerstone holding, and it will continue to represent roughly 80% of my self-storage allocation.

But scale isn’t the only story worth telling. Recently, I’ve taken a small position in Global Self Storage (SELF), a much smaller REIT with only 13 properties across several states. At first glance, SELF’s size might seem like a disadvantage compared to CUBE’s national footprint. Yet its dividend yield—currently 5.81%—is notably higher, offering an opportunity to compound income more aggressively. For an investor focused on transparency and long-term growth, that yield is worth exploring, even if the risks are greater.

Of course, payout ratios tell a cautionary tale. SELF’s dividend payout exceeds its net income, raising questions about sustainability. By contrast, CUBE’s dividend is well-covered when measured against Funds From Operations (FFO), the preferred metric for REITs. This difference underscores why I’m keeping SELF to just 3% of my self-storage allocation for now. It’s a tactical position: enough to benefit from the yield and potential growth, but not so large that it jeopardizes the stability of my compounding strategy.

The balance between reliability and opportunity is at the heart of this decision. CUBE provides the institutional strength and dividend security that underpins my portfolio. SELF, meanwhile, represents a calculated bet on a smaller player with higher yield potential. Together, they create a blend of stability and growth—an approach that allows me to compound income while staying diversified.

In the end, investing is about more than chasing yield or clinging to scale. It’s about constructing a portfolio that reflects both caution and curiosity. By maintaining CUBE as my foundation and adding SELF as a small but intentional position, I’m aiming to capture the best of both worlds: dependable income and the possibility of outsized growth.

I like the Real Estate Sector, and Self-Storage is important and preferred. I will equally grow these two together. I value that SELF has focus on revamping, or restoring, as I perceived, Self-Storage Properties that exist.